sacocoon
2020-11-09 11:11:00.0
已经投稿20天了，依然是状态Submission，上周发了邮件给编辑也没有回复。不知道MMTA编辑们最近在忙什么。。。
奥氏体不锈钢
2020-09-26 10:37:00.0
Stage Start Date Waiting for Revision 2020-06-04 Decision Made 2020-06-04 Decision Pending 2020-05-31 Manuscript Revise and Re-Review 2020-05-31 Decision Made 2020-05-31 Under Review 2020-05-01 Under Consideration 2020-04-30 2020-04-20 Submission 2020-04-19 Stage Start Date Waiting for Revision 2020-09-08 Decision Made 2020-09-08 Decision Pending 2020-09-08 Manuscript Revise Only 2020-09-08 Decision Made 2020-09-08 Under Review 2020-08-19 Under Consideration 2020-08-18 Submission 2020-08-18 Manuscript Accepted 2020-09-25 Decision Made 2020-09-25 Decision Pending 2020-09-24 Manuscript Decision Made 2020-09-24 Decision Made 2020-09-24 Under Review 2020-09-23 Under Consideration 2020-09-16 Submission 2020-09-16 编辑是大牛Jianfeng Nie, 审稿人是两个，编辑处理和审稿人审稿都挺快的，反倒是我个人拖的时间比较久。按照审稿人要求修改完确实感觉文章档次提高了不少，其中一个审稿人还不厌其烦的从头到尾的给我修改了语法，这种一丝不苟的学术态度真的让人钦佩。这个期刊水平挺高的，但受到了IF和审稿时间的影响在国内一直不温不火，实在是可惜。
被禁忌的游戏
2020-05-19 10:59:00.0
这个期刊审稿很认真，有Key reader和两个审稿人来衡量你的文章，提的问题对文章水平有着较大提高，好好回答问题被接收的可能性很高，推荐Jian FengNie主编，人很好很负责。
Mir-ming
2020-03-02 17:08:00.0
Manuscript Sent to Production 2020-02-12 Manuscript Accepted 2020-02-04 Decision Made 2020-02-04 Decision Pending 2020-02-02 Manuscript Decision Made 2020-02-02 Decision Made 2020-02-02 Under Review 2020-01-30 Under Consideration 2020-01-28 Submission 2020-01-22 Waiting for Revision 2020-01-22 Decision Made 2020-01-22 Decision Pending 2020-01-22 Manuscript Revise and Re-Review 2020-01-22 Decision Made 2020-01-22 Under Review 2020-01-14 Under Consideration 2019-12-29 Submission 2019-12-28 Waiting for Revision 2019-12-27 Decision Made 2019-12-27 Decision Pending 2019-12-24 Manuscript Revise and Re-Review 2019-12-24 Decision Made 2019-12-24 Under Review 2019-12-18 Under Consideration 2019-12-12 2019-12-08 Submission 2019-12-08 第一次投这个期刊，还是挺快的，是communication
回头已转角7
2019-07-25 13:50:00.0
研究生第一篇文章，本来投的是corrosion science，被拒后转投MMTA，历时半年终于接收了。 Stage Start Date Manuscript Sent to Production 2019-07-24 Manuscript Accepted 2019-07-22 Decision Made 2019-07-22 Decision Pending 2019-07-22 Manuscript Decision Made 2019-07-22 Decision Made 2019-07-22 Under Consideration 2019-07-16 Submission 2019-07-16 Under Consideration 2019-07-16 Waiting for Revision 2019-07-15 Decision Made 2019-07-15 Decision Pending 2019-07-09 Manuscript Decision Made 2019-07-09 Decision Made 2019-07-09 Under Review 2019-05-28 Under Consideration 2019-05-16 Submission 2019-05-15 Under Consideration 2019-05-16 Waiting for Revision 2019-04-08 Decision Made 2019-04-08 Decision Pending 2019-04-06 Manuscript Revise and Re-Review 2019-04-06 Decision Made 2019-04-06 Under Review 2019-02-08 Under Consideration 2019-01-31 2019-01-22 Submission 2019-01-21
bsun2019
2019-06-15 19:52:00.0
读研究生时，第一篇文章就是投的这个杂志。 那时急需文章评奖学金。 审稿速度很快，一周多就返回来了审稿意见， 感觉是编辑直接审了，因为只有一个审稿人的意见。 修订回去，第三天接收。 赶上了评奖，非常感谢负责的编辑。
weislhitmse
2019-04-16 20:17:00.0
研究方向金属基复合材料的粉末冶金制备、组织调控、高温力学性能。 接近一万字的长文投给冶金会刊A，一个月之内返回两份审稿意见加起来快30条。每条意见都十分中肯，并且审稿人是持以提高文章质量的初衷对待我们的工作。回复意见加起来约4000字返回后二审一个多月直接接收。 冶金会刊A作为传统物理冶金学、结构材料领域的老牌期刊，一直保有扎实严谨的学术作风实属不易。所邀请的审稿人都是领域内直接相关的专家，绝不会一两句话随便打发人，这也许是其审稿周期一直较长的原因。总之作为结构材料出身，得以在冶金会刊A上发一篇长文也算是达成学术生涯一大目标了。下面附上审稿历程（时间倒序）： 一审： Waiting for Revision 2019-02-19 Decision Made 2019-02-19 Decision Pending 2019-02-15 Manuscript Revise and Re-Review 2019-02-15 Decision Made 2019-02-15 Under Review 2019-01-29 Under Consideration 2019-01-24 2019-01-21 Submission 2019-01-21 返修后二审： Manuscript Accepted 2019-04-15 Decision Made 2019-04-15 Decision Pending 2019-04-15 Manuscript Decision Made 2019-04-15 Decision Made 2019-04-15 Under Review 2019-03-08 Under Consideration 2019-03-02 Submission 2019-02-19
huanghe_hugo
2018-09-20 10:39:00.0
两个月收到一审结果（审稿人1和2），然后再三个月后收到审稿人（审稿人1和审稿人3）的意见，编辑给的是Manuscript Revise Only，修改两周后录用。 从投稿到录用历时约6个月。
数据整理自公开网络的投稿反馈，仅供参考。
